DBQ EXERCISE
The growth of Manchester during the nineteenth century had mixed views whether industrialization was either a positive or negative effect on the city. Along with Manchester’s growth, it had many rising issues that the city had to deal with. There were many concerns about the quality of life and welfare of the factory workers due to the over pollution from the inadequate deposal of waste and crowded living space.
Black smoke on brick houses marked the industrial city of Manchester. Robert Southey commented that the streets were over crowded and theses citizens who dwelled in it were only concern with the wretches of their works (doc 2). With such a population living in the city, many health issues were raised hoping to enforce importance of sanitation. Edwin Chadwick reported that the living space of the laboring class was damp and filthy with over crowding dwellings that has bad ventilation (doc 6). The loss of population was even greater than the loss of life from wars. Chadwick’s report can be legitimate since his opinion of Manchester reflects pure motives to keep the city healthy as a public health reformer. Alexis de Tocoqueville also agrees to the outward appearance of the city and the health hazardous with it. She writes that from” the foul drain the greatest stream of human industry of human industry flows out of fertilized the world…this filthy sewers pure gold flows” (doc 5). Though Alexis’ authority maybe questioned, as a foreign visitor, her opinion can be value since those who lives in Manchester are immune to living conditions and may need an outsider’s opinion to stress the seriousness of the health issues.

1 Comments:
nice post phou.
i thought it was well written and you did a good job grouping the documents and doing attributions.
Your first P.O.V. made perfect sense, but i'm not sure i really see the significance of the second P.O.V. I can see how her point of view has to due with the fact that she's a visitor. Does the value of her opinion to the people of Manchester really explain HER view?
I honestly think i just don't understand this P.O.V. stuff well enough. So yours could be perfectly fine. I just need help understanding. lol
but anyways.
great post =]
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home